Outdoor seating area with tables and chairs outside a brick building with a large illuminated sign reading 'Bar Lucy' and window reflections of the street, trees, and buildings under a clear blue sky.

Welcome to Bar Lucy-

Bay Shore’s Favorite Italian Restaurant

Your Neighborhood Italian Restaurant in Bay Shore, NY

Welcome to Bar Lucy, a modern Italian restaurant in the heart of Bay Shore, Long Island, where great food, cocktails, and good company come together. Our guests are family, and we’re here to make every visit feel warm, welcoming, and memorable.

Enjoy handcrafted Italian dishes, fresh pasta, unique pizzettes, seasonal specials, house-made desserts, expertly crafted cocktails, and an inviting selection of wine. Whether you’re joining us for dinner, happy hour, date night, or a special celebration, Bar Lucy offers a warm and intimate setting for every occasion.

Explore our daily specials, fall cocktails, and seasonal dinner menu, then make your reservation today. Walk-ins are always welcome, so stop by and enjoy a meal, cocktail, or glass of wine whenever you’re in the neighborhood.

Prefer to stay in? Order your Bar Lucy favorites online and enjoy our Italian-inspired dishes from the comfort of home.

BOOK YOUR TABLE
A close-up of a pizza topped with pepperoni, basil leaves, and melted cheese on a red and white paper-lined tray.

Dinner Menu

Person pouring a clear liquid from a metal shaker into a patterned cocktail tumbler.

Drink Menu

A black-and-white photo of a man and woman at a restaurant table. The man, in a suit, is feeding the woman a slice of pizza. The woman is smiling with her eyes closed. There are plates, glasses, and a pizza on the table.

Reservations

Pregnant woman in a red dress smiling at a birthday or baby shower celebration, holding her belly, standing outdoors near greenery and a decorated backdrop.

Private Events

BRUNCH | LUNCH & DINNER | COCKTAIL PARTY

Planning a celebration? Host your private event at Bar Lucy or explore our Italian catering services throughout Bay Shore and Long Island. From intimate dinners and birthday parties to bridal showers, corporate events, holiday gatherings, and other special occasions, our team can help create a memorable experience. Visit our Private Events and Catering pages to explore our packages and connect with our events team.

Book Your Dream Party

  • Host your next special occasion at Bar Lucy, where every gathering is designed with intention and effortless charm.

    Our Amalfi Coast Room offers a private, beautifully styled setting ideal for intimate celebrations- from baby showers and birthday parties to rehearsal dinners and bridal events. For larger occasions, Bar Lucy is also available for exclusive full-restaurant reservations, creating a seamless and elevated experience for you and your guests.

    We offer three curated packages: Brunch, Lunch & Dinner, and a whimsical Cocktail Party, all featuring seasonal Italian dishes and handcrafted cocktails, allowing you to tailor every detail to your event.

    Our team is with you every step of the way, ensuring a warm, memorable experience from start to finish.

    Located in the heart of Bay Shore, Bar Lucy is the perfect destination for private events, group dining, and special celebrations on Long Island.

THURSDAY IS

Date Night!

Every Thursday, wine & dine a special someone in your life with:

  • two glasses of wine or Prosecco

  • any appetizer

  • any pizzette

  • two entrees*

  • any dessert

    all for $100

VIEW DAILY SPECIALS
BOOK YOUR TABLE
  • A marble table set with various Italian dishes, including a pizza, pasta, mussels, and roasted vegetables, with empty wine glasses in the background.

    Another fantastic time at Bar Lucy - last time was pasta and chicken dishes, this time it was the salmon and it was delicious but what makes Bar Lucy exceptionally terrific is the outstanding service. Looking forward to returning.

    Michele

  • A slice of lemon cheesecake with whipped cream on top, sitting on a white plate with a decorative border.

    First time dining at Bar Lucy tonight and it was fantastic!

    Christopher

  • A person's hand holding a cocktail glass filled with a dark cocktail against a red padded background.

    We just hosted my wife’s 40th birthday here and it was absolutely fantastic! The booking of the event was simple and easy, the service was some of the best we’ve had, and the team truly went above and beyond to make the night special. The food was a huge hit with everyone, and there was plenty of it. We’ve been here a few times for dinner and knew it would be a great choice, but this exceeded our expectations. So glad we chose this spot, it was truly memorable.

    Francis

  • A close-up of a half-and-half pepperoni pizza with melted cheese and basil leaves on a pizza tray lined with branded paper.

    Chef Freidank and his entire kitchen staff as well as the front of the house were all spot on and made for an enjoyable dinner out. Can't wait to bring my wife and kids.....got to try those pizzas I kept seeing coming out of the kitchen!

    C.J

BAR LUCY CATERING

Bring the taste of Bar Lucy to your next event with timeless Italian flavors made for memorable moments.

Get Started