Welcome to your neighborhood Italian restaurant. At Bar Lucy, our guests are family.
We offer hand-crafted, timeless dishes and expertly-made cocktails in a setting that’s both comfortable and intimate. Enjoy delicious pasta, steak, chicken, wings, pizza, dessert & more.

Make your reservation today! Walk-ins are always welcome. You can also enjoy your Bar Lucy favorites at home by ordering online.

Bay Shore’s Favorite Italian Restaurant

BOOK YOUR TABLE
Person holding a white plate with a baked stuffed mushroom cap and a lemon wedge, with another plate of similar dish on a wooden table.

Dinner Menu

A person's hand holding a cocktail glass with a dark beverage against a red upholstered background.

Drink Menu

Group of people sitting around a wooden table in a restaurant, smiling and enjoying drinks, with a floral bouquet, plates, and napkins on the table.

Reservations

Pregnant woman in a red dress smiling at a birthday or baby shower celebration, holding her belly, standing outdoors near greenery and a decorated backdrop.

Private Events

Book Your Dream Party

  • Host your next special occasion at Bar Lucy, where every gathering is designed with intention and effortless charm.

    Our Amalfi Coast Room offers a private, beautifully styled setting ideal for intimate celebrations—from baby showers and birthday parties to rehearsal dinners and bridal events. For larger occasions, Bar Lucy is also available for exclusive full-restaurant reservations, creating a seamless and elevated experience for you and your guests.

    We offer curated food and beverage packages featuring seasonal Italian dishes and handcrafted cocktails, allowing you to tailor every detail to your event. Our team is with you every step of the way, ensuring a warm, memorable experience from start to finish.

    Located in the heart of Bay Shore, Bar Lucy is the perfect destination for private events, group dining, and special celebrations on Long Island.

A slice of lemon cheesecake topped with whipped cream on a white plate with a red background.
VIEW DAILY SPECIALS

  • First time dining at Bar Lucy tonight and it was fantastic!

    —CHRISTOPHER

  • Another fantastic time at Bar Lucy - last time was pasta and chicken dishes, this time it was the salmon and it was delicious but what makes Bar Lucy exceptionally terrific is the outstanding service. Looking forward to returning.

    —MICHELE

  • We just hosted my wife’s 40th birthday here and it was absolutely fantastic! The booking of the event was simple and easy, the service was some of the best we’ve had, and the team truly went above and beyond to make the night special. The food was a huge hit with everyone, and there was plenty of it. We’ve been here a few times for dinner and knew it would be a great choice, but this exceeded our expectations. So glad we chose this spot, it was truly memorable. Thank you to the whole staff!

    —FRANCIS

  • Chef Freidank and his entire kitchen staff as well as the front of the house were all spot on and made for an enjoyable dinner out. Can't wait to bring my wife and kids.....got to try those pizzas I kept seeing coming out of the kitchen!

    —C.J

  • This was our first time at Bar Lucy, and it definitely won’t be our last. From the moment we sat down, our server was incredibly attentive and knowledgeable. The kind of server who elevates the entire experience without ever hovering or rushing you through your meal.

    —MS. S

  • It was Tuesday pasta night (such a great deal), and everything came out fresh and perfectly timed. Great food, cozy atmosphere, and outstanding service. We would absolutely go back.

    —JACQUEULINE

  • I had the cacio e pepe, which was rich, simple, and executed beautifully, while Q had the bolognese with steak, which was absolutely incredible and that ✨️steak✨️ was cooked perfectly. We ended the night sharing the chocolate budino, and it was the perfect way to wrap up the meal, decadent without being overwhelming. CAN'T WAIT TO COME BACK!

    -J.S

  • The crispy fried artichokes were perfectly cooked and delicious. My father's Mussels were excellent and the bread dipped in the broth really brought out all the flavors. My linguini with shrimp and scallops was great and a much larger portion than I was expecting. And the tiramisu.....I'm not usually a fan but my dad got it and I tasted it and now I am!

    —CHRIS

A plate of cheese and basil pizza with melted cheese, tomato sauce, green basil leaves, on a white dish with green lines.
Close-up of a pepperoni and cheese pizza on branded paper with red and white logo from Bar Lucys, with visible melted cheese, pepperoni slices, and some basil leaves.
A glass dessert cup filled with layered chocolate and cream dessert topped with white chocolate curls.
Close-up of a cheese pizza topped with basil and drizzle of balsamic vinegar, with a slice being pulled away.
Close-up of a plate of fried shrimp with a lemon wedge, a container of dipping sauce, and breaded crumbs.
A colorful arrangement of flowers, oranges, and a glass of orange-colored drink on a white table outdoors.